Biol Reprod
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


This Article
Right arrow Abstract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Right arrow Citation Map
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow reprints & permissions
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow PubMed Citation
Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.
Agricola
Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.
Biology of Reproduction 66, 1151-1160 (2002)
© 2002 Society for the Study of Reproduction, Inc.


Regular Article

Ultrastructure of the Resting Ovarian Follicle Pool in Healthy Young Women1

J.P. de Bruin2,,a, M. Dorlandb, E.R. Spekc, G. Posthumad, M. van Haaftena, C.W.N. Loomane, and E.R. te Veldef

a Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Diakonessenhuis Utrecht, 3582 KE Utrecht, The Netherlands b Department of Human Genetics, University Medical Centre Utrecht, 3584 CX Utrecht, The Netherlands c Department of Biochemistry, Cell Biology and Histology, University of Utrecht, 3584 CM Utrecht, The Netherlands d Department of Cell Biology, University Medical Centre Utrecht, 3584 CX Utrecht, The Netherlands e Department of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine, Erasmus University Rotterdam, 3000 DR Rotterdam, The Netherlands f Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University Medical Centre Utrecht, 3584 CX Utrecht, The Netherlands


    ABSTRACT
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 REFERENCES
 
In humans, follicle quantity and quality decline with age by atresia. In the present study we aimed to describe the quality of the follicle pool through an ultrastructural investigation of resting follicles in young healthy women. From ovarian biopsies of 7 women aged 25–32 yr, 182 small follicles were morphometrically assessed for various signs of atresia. Morphometric variables were analyzed by principal components analysis (PCA) to demonstrate correlations between variables and to construct an objective follicle score. One third of small follicles consisted of primordial follicles. Nucleus:cell ratios remained constant for oocytes and granulosa cells from primordial to primary follicles, suggesting that follicles up to primary stages belong to the resting pool. The distribution of follicle quality scores as derived from PCA showed that most follicles were of good quality and with little signs of atresia. Atresia in resting follicles appears to be a necrotic process, starting in the ooplasma. Early atresia was characterized by increasing numbers of multivesicular bodies and lipid droplets, dilation of smooth endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi, and irregular mitochondria with changed matrix density. In progressive atresia mitochondrial membranes ruptured, oocyte nuclear membranes were indented or ruptured, and the ooplasma showed extensive vacuolarization. The early involvement of mitochondria in this process suggests that damage is induced by oxygen radicals. PCA follicle quality scores can be reliably approximated using a reduced number of seven morphometric variables, which were selected by stepwise forward analysis. The algorithm to calculate these follicle scores is presented.

aging, apoptosis, follicle, granulosa cells, ovary, ovum


    INTRODUCTION
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 REFERENCES
 
At birth, human ovaries contain their lifetime store of follicles (oocytes surrounded by granulosa cells). Thereafter, the number of follicles declines until exhaustion at menopause [1, 2]. In addition, the quality of follicles decreases with age. This is illustrated by declines in pregnancy and implantation rates in in vitro fertilization, which can be abrogated by the use of oocytes from young donors [3]. Follicle quantity and quality cannot be separated. Factors that influence follicle quality will also influence follicle numbers, because follicles will degenerate before they disappear. Ultimately, this will also influence reproductive potential.

Although the decline in follicle number concomitant with age has been established accurately, we have limited knowledge of the changes in follicle quality associated with age and the factors that govern these changes. As follicles "rest" in the ovaries for up to 50 yr, degenerative changes will probably accumulate in oocytes and granulosa cells [4]. According to the production line hypothesis, follicle quality is determined in utero; the best follicles are formed first in fetal life and are recruited first during reproductive life, whereas follicles of poor quality are formed later, and are recruited later. Accordingly, as women age, an increasing proportion of their follicles are of poor quality [5, 6]. The concept that follicle quality declines with age is further complicated by the dynamics of the follicle population. Follicles leave the resting pool on a regular basis and pass through subsequent developmental stages, but most degenerate and very few reach the final stage of ovulation [7]; in addition, at various developmental stages, follicles probably behave differently in response to degeneration-inducing factors [8].

In recent years, cryopreservation of ovarian tissue, in vitro development of immature follicles, and reproductive aging have become major research issues in reproductive biology, and assessment of follicle quality is of paramount importance in these disciplines, both in order to examine the decline in quality during freezing or tissue culture, and to investigate the age-related decline in follicle quality. It is clear that research in these areas will benefit from a better understanding of the cellular mechanisms that determine follicle quality and a method for objectively describing follicle quality in the human ovary.

Follicular degeneration, commonly referred to as atresia, is accompanied by ultrastructural, morphological changes in oocytes and granulosa cells. A number of studies have endeavored to describe these morphological signs of atresia in resting follicles, and a firm agreement for several signs can be found among these studies (Table 1).


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
TABLE 1. Morphological signs of atresia in small ovarian follicles, as uniformly reported in relevant studies (numbers in brackets indicate the reference number)

We carried out a systematic morphometric investigation of the ultrastructure of the human resting follicle pool in a group of young healthy women who were not yet expected to show signs of age-related fertility decline [9] and whose follicles were likely to be of normal quality. Our aims were to 1) investigate the ultrastructural characteristics of the pool of resting follicles, 2) determine the distribution of resting follicles with and without signs of atresia, and 3) develop a method by which follicle quality could be objectively assessed.


    MATERIALS AND METHODS
 TOP
 ABSTRACT
 INTRODUCTION
 MATERIALS AND METHODS
 RESULTS
 DISCUSSION
 REFERENCES
 
Materials

Healthy women aged 25–32 yr were recruited from a group of patients who requested tubal sterilization. Each woman provided informed consent and allowed us to collect small ovarian biopsies during surgery. Permission to perform the assessment was also granted by the local ethics committee.

Women were selected on the basis of proven fertility (spontaneous pregnancy achieved within the last 12 mo), a regular menstrual cycle (cycle length 21–35 days, maximum intercycle difference 7 days), no endocrinological pathology, no use of oral contraceptives in the previous 2 mo, and in good general health as assessed by a questionnaire.

Women were scheduled for laparoscopic surgery in the preovulatory phase of the menstrual cycle as determined by transvaginal ultrasonography (dominant follicle >15 mm). With a biopsy forceps (Storz, Munich, Germany), two biopsies of ovarian cortex of {approx}3 x 3 mm were taken from the ovary that contained the dominant follicle. Biopsies were taken from a part of the ovarian cortex that was devoid of corpora albicantia and antral follicles bulging at the surface, and at a clear distance from the dominant follicle.

Histology

Biopsies were fixed immediately after biopsy by immersion in fresh Karnovsky fixative (2.5% glutaraldehyde and 2% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M Na-cacodylate buffer, pH 7.3) for 60 min, and postfixed for 3 h in 2% osmium tetroxide in the same buffer. Samples were than stained en bloc with 2% aqueous uranyl acetate for 3 h, followed by dehydration in a graded series of acetone, and embedding in Durcupan ACM (Fluka, Buchs, Switzerland).

Because primordial or primary follicles measure about 25–75 µm in diameter [10], semithin sections (1 µm) were cut on an LKB III microtome at intervals of 50 µm throughout each biopsy, stained with toluidine blue, and screened for the presence of follicles by light microscopy.

Ultrathin sections (50–70 nm), corresponding to selected sections containing follicles, were prepared with a diamond knife on an LKB V ultramicrotome and mounted on single-slot formvar-carbon-coated copper grids. After staining with Reynold lead citrate [11], the sections were examined, and random small follicles with a visible oocyte nucleus were photographed with a transmission electron microscope (CM 10 Philips, Eindhoven, The Netherlands) at 80 kV (microscope magnification for a general view 1650x and 2950x for detail photographs).

Morphometry

Negatives were scanned (Agfa Duoscan; Agfa Gevaert GmbH., Köln, Germany) at a resolution of 1120 pixels per inch and analyzed with an image analysis software program (Scion Image ß release 3b; Scion Corp., Frederick, MD). Further calculations were performed with a statistical software program (SPSS release 8.0; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL).

We designed the following set of morphometric variables based on the signs of atresia that are presented in Table 1:

  • Profile areas of the oocyte, the oocyte nucleus, granulosa cells, and granulosa cell nuclei were measured. Only those oocytes and granulosa cells with a visible nucleus were assessed. Nucleus-to-cell ratios were calculated from these measurements for both oocytes and granulosa cells.
  • The total profile areas of free lipid droplets, multivesicular bodies, vacuoles, Golgi complexes, and mitochondria in the oocyte profile were measured. The cytoplasmic fractions for these structures were calculated as the total profile area of the structure divided by the profile area of the oocyte minus the profile area of the oocyte nucleus.
  • The profile area of all mitochondria in the oocyte profile were individually measured and the mean profile area per oocyte calculated.
  • The following discrete variables from Table 1 were scored for oocytes and granulosa cells.

    Oocytes Nuclear membrane intact, or indented or ruptured; mitochondrial membranes intact with parallel or transverse cristae, intact with arch-like cristae or ruptured; mitochondrial matrix low, moderate, or high density; smooth endoplasmic reticulum (SER) flat or dilated and their location close (associated) or distant (dissociated) to the mitochondria; number of microvilli low or high; the Golgi complex absent or present in the oocyte profile; and the Golgi saccular membranes flat or dilated. Condensation of the oocyte chromatin was not separately scored because this was observed in only 1 out of 182 follicles. Rough endoplasmatic reticulum (RER) was not scored because it was scarce in oocytes.

    Granulosa cells Chromatin condensation high or low; electron density of the cytoplasm high or low; mitochondrial membranes intact or ruptured; SER and RER flat or dilated. For further calculations these individual granulosa cell scores were expressed as scores per follicle (i.e., the proportion of granulosa cells with low condensation of the chromatin, the proportion of cells with low density of the cytoplasm, the proportion of cells with intact mitochondria and the proportion of cells with flat SER and RER). The aspect of the Golgi complex in the granulosa cells was not scored because the frequency of Golgi visible in the granulosa cell profiles was very low.

    Three variables, which were supposed to add quantitative information on the developmental stage of the follicle were included: follicle stage, the absence or partial presence of the zona pellucida, and the number of zonula adherens [1215]. Follicle stage definitions were adopted from those of Lintern-Moore et al. [10]: primordial (primary oocyte surrounded by a single layer of flattened granulosa cells), intermediary (primary oocyte surrounded by a single layer of flattened and cuboidal cells), and primary (primary oocyte surrounded by a single layer of cuboidal granulosa cells).

    Methods of Analysis

    We aimed to construct a follicle quality score from the data of all morphological variables. Therefore, the data matrix of all variables was ordered with a principal components analysis (PCA) [16]. In PCA, a common factor for the variables can be extracted from the correlations between the variables. This common factor, which best explains the total variance of the data matrix, is called the first principal factor. Because we chose morphological variables that reflect follicle quality, we expect that the first principal factor can be assumed to be the best overall reflection of follicle quality.

    Because not all variables are correlated closely, the first principal factor will only partly explain the total variance of the data matrix. A second principal factor can be identified, which explains the variance of the variables not yet represented in the first principal factor. The second principal factor reflects another characteristic of follicular morphology that is not correlated to follicle quality.

    The results of the PCA can be displayed in a two-dimensional graph or biplot [16] in which the horizontal axis represents the first principal factor and the vertical axis represents the second principal factor. The morphological variables are displayed as vectors. The angles between the vectors indicate the correlations between the variables. The length of the vectors indicates the contribution of the variables to the total variance of the data matrix. The positions of the individual follicles are displayed by markers.

    The number of follicles assessed per woman differed a great deal. To remove the undue influence of women with many follicles we weighted the data for the follicles in the PCA with the inverse of the number per woman. Because follicles from the same woman can be expected to be interdependent with respect to quality, developmental stage, or both, we refrained from pooling all follicles. Also, further accounting for subject variance may obscure noteworthy differences in follicle quality per woman. Missing values were few, and therefore, were replaced by the mean of all observations. Classes of discrete variables were included in the PCA individually, except for follicle stage, leading to 38 variables in the PCA. The effect of log-transformation of variables that appeared to be not normally distributed was evaluated, but this had a negligible effect on the outcomes of the PCA.

    Because the first principal factor is assumed to be the best reflection of follicle quality, the position of the individual follicles on the horizontal axis of the biplot can be used to rank follicles by quality. To construct a compact formula for a follicle quality score, the number of variables needed to reliably provide this position was reduced by performing a stepwise forward selection, which runs as follows: in step one the variable with the highest explained variance for the first principal factor is selected. In step two, from all remaining variables the variable is selected that adds the highest explained variance in combination with the variable selected in step one, and so on. The selection was continued until the following step would add less than 0.02 explained variance to the model. If one of the classes of a discrete variable was being selected, all other classes of that variable were included in the same step. All analyses were performed with CANOCO 4.0 for Windows [17].

    For a more detailed description of the statistical model for the PCA, Yki = (Bk1·Xil + Bk2·Xi2) + residual, where Yki = the standardized observation of variable k on follicle i, Bk1 = the variable score for variable k on the first principal factor (horizontal axis in Fig. 1A), Xil = the object score for follicle i on the first principal factor (horizontal axis in Fig. 1B), Bk2 = the variable score for variable k on the second principal factor (vertical axis in Fig. 1A) and Xi2 = the object score for follicle i on the second principal factor (vertical axis in Fig. 1B). Residuals are minimized by least squares approximation.



    View larger version (18K):
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    FIG. 1. A) Principal components analysis on morphological variables; first principal component on horizontal axis, second principal component on vertical axis. Table 3 contains a legend for the numbers. B) Position of individual follicles in the same principal components analysis biplot

    The position of an individual follicle is determined by the sum of the standardized scores of all variables for that particular follicle. Standardization of variable and object scores is rather arbitrary; for example, in the given model, doubling the B's and halving the X's leads to the same outcome of the model. In our analysis, to account for differences in units and scales, we standardized by rescaling the variable scores by subtracting with the mean score value and dividing by the standard deviation of the score value. These standardized scores are multiplied with the X-coordinates of the morphological variables in the biplot, and the sum of these scores provides the X-coordinate of the follicle. The same applies for providing the Y-coordinate.

    For our final score algorithm we rescaled in such a manner that the range of Xi1 runs from 0 to 10 when original (i.e., unstandardized) Yki are used.


        RESULTS
     TOP
     ABSTRACT
     INTRODUCTION
     MATERIALS AND METHODS
     RESULTS
     DISCUSSION
     REFERENCES
     
    Biopsies were taken from 7 women with a mean age of 30.6 yr. From these biopsies a total of 182 small follicles were assessed (Table 2).


    View this table:
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    TABLE 2. Ages of subjects, number of assessed ovarian follicles, median follicle quality scores, and percentiles

    The results of the PCA are displayed in Figure 1, A and B. In Figure 1A the vector numbers correspond to the numbers in Table 3. Variable scores indicating atresia were closely correlated to the first principal factor (horizontal axis); for example, ruptured mitochondrial membranes, the cytoplasmic fraction of lipid droplets, and vacuoles. Variables indicating developmental stage of the follicle; for example, follicle stage and the presence or absence of a zona pellucida, did not correlate well with the first principal factor but were close to the second principal factor (vertical axis). Figure 1B shows the position of all individual follicles in the same biplot. Because the first principal factor represented the variance of all atretic variables, the position of the follicles on the horizontal axis was taken as an objective score for morphological follicle quality. This axis was rescaled, ranging from 0 to 10 points (low to high quality). The distribution of all follicles on this quality scale is shown in Figure 2 and was skewed toward high scores with a median value of 7.3 (10th and 90th percentiles, 4.6 and 8.6). The median follicle score values for each subject are listed in Table 2.


    View this table:
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    TABLE 3. Data of all morphological variables examined, standard deviations in parentheses where appropriate, explained variance in univariate analysis for the first principal factor from the principal components analysis, figure numbers corresponding to Figure 1, variables selected by stepwise forward analysis are printed in bold



    View larger version (10K):
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    FIG. 2. Distribution of follicle quality scores as derived from principal components analysis for all follicles, scores 0–10 run from poor to good quality

    The outcomes of all variables are summarized in Table 3, in which the explained variance for the first principal factor is presented as follows from univariate analysis; for example, in order of importance: ruptured nuclear membranes (0.41), ruptured (0.41) or intact (0.37) mitochondrial membranes, and flat or associated SER (0.31).

    From all follicles 31.5% were at the primordial stage, 54.1% were at the intermediary stage, and 14.4% were at the primary stage. No differences for the areas of the oocytes and the oocyte nuclei or for the nucleus:oocyte ratios were observed for the different follicle stages. The areas of the granulosa cells and granulosa cell nuclei increased significantly from 23.2 to 36.0 µm2 and from 9.5 to 15.2 µm2, respectively, in primordial to primary follicles (ANOVA, P < 0.001). The nucleus:granulosa cell ratio remained constant at 0.42 in primordial to primary follicles.

    Free lipid droplets in the cytoplasm were found in small quantities. In the presence of other atretic signs, the amount of lipid droplets did increase, but lipid droplets were located mainly inside multivesicular bodies. A limited number of small multivesicular bodies was sometimes present in follicles without other signs of atresia, however, numbers and sizes of multivesicular bodies clearly increased when more signs of atresia were noted. Their predominant location was the perinuclear area. Vacuoles were located both centrally and peripherally in the cytoplasm and varied greatly in size. The presence of large numbers of vacuoles was always associated with other signs of atresia. The contents of vacuoles could appear as empty or as amorphous material of low electron density. In several follicles vacuoles appeared to come forth from swollen and at times confluenced vesicles of the SER. Furthermore, big vacuoles developed within the membrane of large multivesicular bodies. The Golgi complex, if it was present, accounted for only a small proportion of the cytoplasmic volume. Generally, a Golgi complex consisted of 5–10 orderly stacked flat saccules. A distinct swelling of these saccules could be noted in association with other atretic signs. Numerous mitochondria were present in nearly all follicles. The profile areas of individual mitochondria showed large variation, ranging from 0.05 to 2.23 µm2.

    No differences for cytoplasmic fractions of lipid droplets, multivesicular bodies, vacuoles, Golgi, mitochondria, and the mean profile area of mitochondria were observed for the different follicle stages. The number of zonula adherens was not clearly related to atretic signs and showed an increase of 1.5 in primordial follicles to 3.7 in primary follicles (P = 0.06).

    In the majority of follicles the oocyte nucleus was centrally placed in the cell with a regular spherical or oval shape. More pronounced indentations and finally rupture of the oocyte nuclear membrane was observed in 32.4% of follicles, and was associated with the accumulation of other atretic signs. Condensation of oocyte chromatin was observed in only 1 out of the 182 follicles. In follicles without signs of atresia the organelles in the oocyte were clustered around the nucleus, and are commonly referred to as Balbiani's vitteline body [18]. Round and elongated mitochondria with parallel or transverse cristae and a matrix of moderate electron density were observed in the majority of follicles (91.8% and 63.7%, respectively). With mounting signs of atresia a reduction of the number of mitochondrial cristae was observed together with a changing density (high or low) of the matrix. Furthermore, mitochondrial shape became irregular and ultimately, mitochondrial membranes ruptured. SER was abundant in all oocytes in vesicular and tubular form. In 65.9% of follicles vesicles were small and tubules were flat and in close association to the mitochondria. In association with other atretic signs, a dilation of SER occurred, and the association with mitochondria was lost. In 25.3% of follicles the assessed cross-section did not contain Golgi complexes in the oocyte. In association with other signs of atresia, Golgi saccules became dilated. The numbers of microvilli were small in most follicles (62.6%). These numbers did not seem to be influenced by follicle health, but by follicle stage: many microvilli were seen in 28% of primordial, 40% of intermediary, and 46% of primary follicles. The (partial) presence of a zona pellucida was also related to follicle stage and increased from 7% to 19% from primordial to primary follicles. No relation with follicle stage was observed for the other variables.

    In 79.7% of granulosa cells condensation of the chromatin was low. In the other granulosa cells patches of condensed chromatin along the nuclear membrane were associated with alterations of cell organelles and increased electron density of the cytoplasm. A small proportion of granulosa cells (3.2%) contained ruptured mitochondria. SER and RER were generally flat (88.5%) in granulosa cells, but were found dilated in dark granulosa cells. Dark (condensed chromatin, high electron density of cytoplasm) and light (uncondensed chromatin, low electron density of cytoplasm) granulosa cells were found adjacent in follicles that contained oocytes with and without signs of atresia. Several follicles could be found with nearly destroyed oocytes, still surrounded by a number of light granulosa cells.

    The results of the stepwise forward selection for explained variance of the first principal factor are shown in Table 4. The selected variables are also indicated in Table 3. Seven variables were selected, which explained 93% of the variance of the scores based on all variables (SD = 0.44 for the 10-point follicle quality scale). The first selected variable, the presence of ruptured mitochondrial membranes, explained a large proportion of the quality score. Other obvious markers of atresia were not selected because they were closely correlated to the presence of ruptured mitochondrial membranes, and therefore added little to the explained variance. In other words, after each selection step of the analysis the order of importance of the remaining variables changes depending on their correlation with earlier selected variables, which explains why some variables that have a higher explained variance from univariate analysis as listed in Table 3 are not selected, whereas other variables with a lower explained variance in univariate analysis are. This is the case, for example, with the mean area of the oocyte that gains importance over the mean area of the oocyte nucleus after selection step 4 (Table 4).


    View this table:
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    TABLE 4. Results of stepwise forward selection for explained variance of morphological variables for the first principal factor, algorithm to calculate follicle quality score from the selected variables, and example calculations for the follicles from Figure 3

    From the seven selected variables, five reflect atretic signs present in the oocyte and two reflect atretic signs in the granulosa cells. From the selected parameters, follicle quality score can be calculated with the algorithm in Table 4, which includes two examples of such calculations for the follicles shown in Figure 3. Figure 4 shows further examples of morphological variables in healthy and atretic situations.



    View larger version (147K):
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    FIG. 3. 1A) Primary follicle of good quality. The oocyte nucleus is large with a regular membrane; the mitochondria are clustered around the nucleus; and multivesicular bodies, lipid droplets, and vacuoles are absent. The granulosa cells have large nuclei with uncondensed chromatin and cytoplasm of low electron density, in which many mitochondria are present. Bar = 5 µm. 1B) Detail of 1A; mitochondria with intact membranes, transverse cristae, and a matrix of moderate electron density. Bar = 300 nm. 1C) Detail of 1A; SER in flat tubular and vesicular form. Bar = 200 nm. For follicle quality score calculation, see example 1 in Table 4. 2A) Intermediary follicle of poor quality. The membranes of the oocyte nucleus and the mitochondria are ruptured, numerous small vacuoles and a number of lipid droplets are present in the ooplasm. One granulosa cell shows condensation of chromatin on the nuclear membrane. Bar = 5 µm. 2B) Detail of 2A; mitochondria with ruptured outer membranes, and the cristae are largely destroyed. Bar = 250 nm. 2C) Detail of 2A; SER in swollen tubular and vesicular form. Bar = 250 nm. For follicle quality score calculation see example 2 in Table 4



    View larger version (135K):
    [in this window]
    [in a new window]
     
    FIG. 4. Examples of morphological variables of resting ovarian follicles in healthy and atretic situations. Detail of three oocytes from intermediary follicles with mitochondria of moderate (1A), low (1B), and high (1C) density of the matrix. 2A) Detail of an oocyte from an intermediary follicle. There are no signs of atresia, and the nucleus (right side of picture) is regularly shaped. Intact mitochondria and two Golgi complexes (left side of picture) are present centrally in the cytoplasma. 2B) Detail of an oocyte from an intermediary follicle. The nucleus (upper left corner of picture) is regularly shaped. In contrast to 2A, atretic signs are present in the cytoplasma in the form of lipid droplets and multivesicular bodies. 3A) A healthy granulosa cell from a primary follicle. The chromatin is uncondensed, the cytoplasma is of low density, the mitochondria are small and intact, and SER is flat. 3B) Detail of an atretic granulosa cell from a primary follicle. The chromatin is condensed along the nuclear membrane, the cristae of the mitochondria are largely destroyed, and the SER is dilated. For all panels, bar = 2 µm


        DISCUSSION
     TOP
     ABSTRACT
     INTRODUCTION
     MATERIALS AND METHODS
     RESULTS
     DISCUSSION
     REFERENCES
     
    The studied follicles were harvested from the ovaries of fertile women around 30 yr of age. Only small preantral follicles were sampled because we aimed to describe the quality of the resting follicle pool. Generally, it is assumed that primordial follicles make up the vast majority of the resting follicle pool [4]. However, the distribution of follicle stages showed that only a third of all small follicles consisted of primordial follicles. The majority were at the intermediary stage, and a considerable proportion were at the primary stage. Sizes of oocytes, oocyte nuclei, and their ratios did not change with follicle stage up to the primary stage. A study on follicles in human fetal ovaries showed comparable findings [19]. Likewise, in bovine ovaries, more than 80% of follicles were found to be at the intermediary or primary stage [15]. Obviously, granulosa cells and granulosa cell nuclei in the present study showed a clear increase with follicle stage. However, the nucleus:granulosa cell ratio remained remarkably constant up to the primary stage. All findings confirm Gougeon hypothesis that follicles up to the primary stage belong to the resting follicle pool. This pool may be more heterogeneous than has been previously believed and constitutes primary oocytes surrounded by variously formed granulosa cells, from flat to cuboidal. These follicles are probably not quiescent, but show a sluggish growth toward the primary stage, which may take several decades, and enter the rapid growth phase only at the transition to the secondary stage [20, 21]. That FSH receptors appear on the granulosa cells only when the primary stage has been reached, together with the body of evidence that FSH is likely to facilitate the initiation of follicle growth, further support Gougeon hypothesis [22, 23]. Therefore, morphological data of primordial, intermediary, and primary follicles were used to investigate the quality of the resting follicle pool.

    Our aim was to describe the morphology of the resting follicle pool and to construct an objective method to use the morphological variables for a follicle quality score. This was attempted by running a PCA on all variables. The first principal factor predominantly explained the variance of atretic signs, which generally correlated well with this factor. Thus, the first principal factor seemed to accurately reflect quality, and the horizontal axis in the PCA biplot was taken as the gradient on which follicles can be placed, according to their quality. The distribution of follicles along this axis on a scale of 0–10 showed that most resting follicles were of good quality, showing little signs of atresia. It should be noted that a very small number of follicles showed such severe atretic changes that morphometry could not be performed reliably, and were therefore excluded from the analysis.

    From light-microscopic studies, although at that level more subtle signs of atresia could have remained obscure, similar findings of a low rate of atresia have been reported [2, 7, 24, 25]. Apparently, resting follicles accumulate little damage, which may be associated with their low metabolic rate [22]. The increase in atresia may occur only after the initiation of rapid follicle growth.

    The second principal factor grouped variables such as follicle stage and zona pellucida score, suggesting a reflection of follicle development. Follicle development did not correlate well with most atretic signs, indicating that in resting follicles the rate of atresia is not different for primordial, intermediary, or primary follicles.

    The combination of atretic signs in follicles suggest a distinct sequence in which degenerative changes take place. The presence of few atretic signs suggest early atresia. These few signs were frequently the same; for example, multivesicular bodies and lipid droplets. Other signs, for example, indentation or rupture of the nuclear membrane, were frequently found in association with the presence of a larger number of atretic signs, suggesting progressive atresia.

    Accordingly, the following sequence of degenerative changes in resting follicles can be hypothesized. First, an increase of multivesicular bodies and lipid droplets is noted. Next, the SER dissociates from the mitochondria and a rapid accumulation of vacuoles occurs. Thereafter, the nuclear membrane begins to show indentations and mitochondria become more irregularly shaped with a reduction of cristae and changing density of the matrix. The SER and Golgi show progressive swelling, the SER even transforms to large vacuoles. In terminal phases of atresia mitochondrial membranes rupture, leaving empty remains of mitochondrial structures, nuclear membranes show large indentations or ruptures, and the largest part of the cytoplasm consists of small to very large vacuoles.

    According to this sequence of degenerative changes, atresia in resting follicles appears to be a process of necrosis and not of apoptosis. Necrosis, which is a result of environmental injuries, changes the cellular appearance by increased permeability of membranes, destruction of cytoplasmic structures, and finally nuclear degeneration. Apoptosis, or programmed cell death, starts with cellular and chromatin condensation (pycnosis), which in our material, was observed in only 1 out of the 182 examined follicles. In apoptosis, pycnosis is followed by nuclear and plasma membranes becoming irregular and cell organelles remaining intact until the final stages of cell death [26, 27]. Cytogenetic studies also failed to demonstrate apoptosis in resting follicles. In contrast, the role of apoptosis in atresia of growing follicles is firmly established [28, 29]. However, it is possible that apoptosis could not be demonstrated in resting follicles because of the high pace of the apoptotic process and the supposed low rate of atresia in these follicles [2, 7, 24]. Furthermore, considering the low rate of atresia in our sample of resting follicles, we cannot draw final conclusions from the present study on the characteristics of the atretic process.

    Because healthy granulosa cells were frequently present in follicles with degenerative oocytes, it seems that in resting follicles atresia starts in the oocyte, which is in line with the findings of other researchers [8, 30]. In contrast, atresia in growing follicles has been shown to start in granulosa cell layers [8, 24, 31]. In these follicles the granulosa cells probably shield the oocyte from environmental insults.

    The early involvement of mitochondria in the atretic process suggests a role for oxygen radical-induced damage. Oxygen radicals induce cellular damage as they accumulate with age. The mitochondria would be the first organelles to show degenerative signs because they are the site of oxygen radical production, and accumulation of mitochondrial DNA deletions with age has been shown [3234].

    Scoring all variables to determine follicle quality is laborious and not practical if large numbers of follicles are to be assessed. Several variables make only a small contribution to the total variance of the data. Therefore, we reduced the number of variables by stepwise forward selection to a much smaller number that would still closely approximate the original PCA quality score. From our selection, seven variables resulted with an explained variance of the original score of 93%. Five of these variables reflected atretic signs in the oocyte, which is in line with the assumption that the oocyte mainly determines the quality and fate of a resting follicle. The algorithm to calculate the score from these variables is presented. With this algorithm follicle scores can be obtained for those aiming to compare follicle populations on atresia (examples in Fig. 3 and Table 4). Of course, the biological and clinical relevance of this general follicle quality score needs further evaluation and validation. We hope future studies will be undertaken to test the value of this score for more specific applications, such as investigations on the effects of tissue culture, cryopreservation, or aging.


        FOOTNOTES
     
    First decision: 5 February 2001.

    1 Financial support was received from Serono Benelux, Abbott. Back

    2 Correspondence: J.P. de Bruin, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Diakonessenhuis Utrecht, Bosboomstraat 1, 3582 KE Utrecht, The Netherlands. FAX: 31 30 2505433; jp{at}debruin-kers.demon.nl Back

    Accepted: October 25, 2001.

    Received: January 20, 2001.


        REFERENCES
     TOP
     ABSTRACT
     INTRODUCTION
     MATERIALS AND METHODS
     RESULTS
     DISCUSSION
     REFERENCES
     

    1. Faddy MJ, Gosden RG, Gougeon A, Richardson J, Nelson JF. Accelerated disappearance of ovarian follicles in mid-life: implications for forecasting menopause. Hum Reprod 1992; 7:1342-1346[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    2. Richardson SJ, Senikas V, Nelson JF. Follicular depletion during the menopausal transition: evidence for accelerated loss and ultimate exhaustion. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1987; 65:1231-1237[Abstract]
    3. Navot D, Bergh PA, Williams MA, Garrisi GJ, Guzman I, Sandler B, Grunfeld L. Poor oocyte quality rather than implantation failure as a cause of age-related decline in female fertility. Lancet 1991; 337::1375-1377[CrossRef][Medline]
    4. Gosden RG. Oocyte development throughout life. In: Grudzinskas JG, Yovich JI (eds.), Cambridge Reviews in Human Reproduction, Gametes—The Oocyte. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1995: 150–182
    5. Henderson SA, Edwards RG. Chiasma frequency and maternal age in mammals. Nature 1968; 218:22-28
    6. Hirshfield AN. Heterogeneity of cell populations that contribute to the formation of primordial follicles in rats. Biol Reprod 1992; 47:466-472[Abstract]
    7. Faddy MJ, Gosden RG. A mathematical model of follicle dynamics in the human. Hum Reprod 1995; 10:770-775[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    8. Gougeon A, Testart J. Germinal vesicle breakdown in oocytes of human atretic follicles during the menstrual cycle. J Reprod Fertil 1986; 78:389-401[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    9. van Noord-Zaadstra BM, Looman CWN, Alsbach H, Habbema JDF, te Velde ER, Karbaat J. Delaying childbearing: effect of age on fecundity and outcome of pregnancy. Br Med J 1991; 302:1361-1365
    10. Lintern-Moore S, Peters H, Moore GPM, Faber M. Follicular development in the infant human ovary. J Reprod Fertil 1974; 39:53-64[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    11. Reynold ES. The use of lead citrate at high pH as an electron opaque stain in electron microscopy. J Cell Biol 1963; 17:208-212[Free Full Text]
    12. Fair T, Hulshof SCJ, Hyttel P, Greve T, Boland M. Oocyte ultrastructure in bovine primordial to early tertiary follicles. Anat Embryol 1997; 195:327-336[CrossRef][Medline]
    13. Motta PM, Makabe S, Naguro T, Correr S. Oocyte follicle cells association during development of human ovarian follicle. A study by high resolution scanning and transmission electron microscopy. Arch Histol Cytol 1994; 57:369-394[Medline]
    14. Dvorak M, Tesarik J. Ultrastructure of human ovarian follicles. In: Motta PM, Hafez ESE (eds.), Biology of the Ovary. The Hague, The Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff; 1980: 121–137
    15. van Wezel I, Rodgers RJ. Morphological characterization of bovine primordial follicles in their environment in vivo. Biol Reprod 1996; 55:1003-1011[Abstract]
    16. Gower JC, Hand DJ. Biplots. London: Chapman and Hall; 1996
    17. Ter Braak CJF. Ordination. In: Jongman RHG, ter Braak CJF, van Tongeren OFR (eds.), Data Analysis in Community and Landscape Ecology. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1995: 91–173
    18. Guraya SS. Correlation between the findings of light and electron microscopy in human primordial follicles. Acta Anat 1970; 77:617-635[Medline]
    19. de Bruin JP, Nikkels PGJ, Bruinse HW, van Haaften M, Looman CWN, te Velde ER. Morphometry of human ovaries in normal and growth restricted fetuses. Early Hum Dev 2001; 60:179-192[CrossRef][Medline]
    20. Gougeon A, Chainy GBN. Morphometric studies of small follicles in ovaries of women at different ages. J Reprod Fertil 1987; 81:433-442[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    21. Gosden RG, Bownes M. Molecular and cellular aspects of oocyte development. In: Grudzinskas JG, Yovich JI (eds.), Cambridge Reviews in Human Reproduction, Gametes—The Oocyte. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press; 1995: 119–149
    22. Oktay K, Nugent D, Newton H, Salha O, Chatterjee P, Gosden RG. Isolation and characterization of primordial follicles from fresh and cryopreserved human ovarian tissue. Fertil Steril 1997; 67:481-486[CrossRef][Medline]
    23. te Velde ER, Scheffer GJ, Dorland M, Broekmans FJ, Fauser BC. Developmental and endocrine aspects of normal ovarian aging. Mol Cell Endocrinol 1998; 145:67-73[CrossRef][Medline]
    24. Himelstein-Braw R, Byskov AG, Peters H, Faber M. Follicular atresia in the infant human ovary. J Reprod Fertil 1976; 46:55-59[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    25. de Pol A, Vaccina F, Forabosco A, Cavazutti E, Marzona L. Apoptosis of germ cells during human prenatal oogenesis. Hum Reprod 1997; 12:2235-2241[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    26. Kerr JFR, Wyllie AH, Currie AR. Apoptosis: a basic biological phenomenon with wide-ranging implications in tissue kinetics. Br J Cancer 1972; 26:239-257[Medline]
    27. Wyllie AH, Currie AR, Kerr JFR. Cell death: the significance of apoptosis. Int Rev Cytol 1980; 68:251-306[Medline]
    28. Tilly JL, Kowalsky KI, Johnson AL, Hsueh AJW. Involvement of apoptosis in ovarian follicular atresia and postovulatory regression. Endocrinology 1991; 129:2799-2801[Abstract]
    29. Yuan W, Giudice LC. Programmed cell death in human ovary is a function of follicle and corpus luteum status. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 1997; 82:3148-3155[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    30. Tassell R, Kennedy JP. Early follicular development and atretic changes in the ovary of the lamb—fine structure and histochemistry. Aust J Biol Sci 1980; 33:675-687[Medline]
    31. Tilly JL, Kowalski KI, Schomberg DW, Hsueh AJ. Apoptosis in atretic ovarian follicles is associated with selective decreases in messenger ribonucleic acid transcripts for gonadotropin receptors and cytochrome P450 aromatase. Endocrinology 1992; 131:1670-1676[Abstract]
    32. Harman D. The biological clock: the mitochondria?. J Am Geriatr Soc 1972; 4:145-147
    33. Kitagawa T, Suganuma N, Nawa A, Kikkawa F, Tanaka M, Ozawa T, Tomoda Y. Rapid accumulation of deleted mitochondrial deoxyribonucleic acid in postmenopausal ovaries. Biol Reprod 1993; 49:730-736[Abstract]
    34. Keefe DL, Niven-Fairchild T, Powell S, Buradagunta S. Mitochondrial deoxyribonucleic acid deletions in oocytes and reproductive aging in women. Fertil Steril 1995; 64:577-583[Medline]
    35. Stankova J, Cech S. Ultrastructural changes during atresia of human ovarian follicles; I. Primordial follicles. Z Mikrosk Anat Forsch 1983; 97:915-928[Medline]
    36. Familiari G, Caggiati A, Nottola SA, Ermini M, di Benedetto MR, Motta PM. Ultrastructure of human ovarian primordial follicles after combination chemotherapy for Hodgkin's disease. Hum Reprod 1993; 8:2080-2087[Abstract/Free Full Text]
    37. Sathananthan AH. Ultrastructure of the human egg. Hum Cell 1997; 10:21-38[Medline]



    This article has been cited by other articles:


    Home page
    Hum Reprod UpdateHome page
    C. Tatone, F. Amicarelli, M. C. Carbone, P. Monteleone, D. Caserta, R. Marci, P. G. Artini, P. Piomboni, and R. Focarelli
    Cellular and molecular aspects of ovarian follicle ageing
    Hum. Reprod. Update, March 1, 2008; 14(2): 131 - 142.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Hum ReprodHome page
    C. G. Westergaard, A. G. Byskov, and C. Y. Andersen
    Morphometric characteristics of the primordial to primary follicle transition in the human ovary in relation to age
    Hum. Reprod., August 1, 2007; 22(8): 2225 - 2231.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Hum ReprodHome page
    P. R. Hurst, J. M. Mora, and M. A. Fenwick
    Caspase-3, TUNEL and ultrastructural studies of small follicles in adult human ovarian biopsies
    Hum. Reprod., August 1, 2006; 21(8): 1974 - 1980.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Hum ReprodHome page
    M.-M. Dolmans, N. Michaux, A. Camboni, B. Martinez-Madrid, A. Van Langendonckt, S. Annarita Nottola, and J. Donnez
    Evaluation of Liberase, a purified enzyme blend, for the isolation of human primordial and primary ovarian follicles
    Hum. Reprod., February 1, 2006; 21(2): 413 - 420.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Hum Reprod UpdateHome page
    R. G. Gosden
    Germline stem cells in the postnatal ovary: is the ovary more like a testis?
    Hum. Reprod. Update, May 1, 2004; 10(3): 193 - 195.
    [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Biol. Reprod.Home page
    J.P. de Bruin, M. Dorland, E.R. Spek, G. Posthuma, M. van Haaften, C.W.N. Looman, and E.R. te Velde
    Age-Related Changes in the Ultrastructure of the Resting Follicle Pool in Human Ovaries
    Biol Reprod, February 1, 2004; 70(2): 419 - 424.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Biol. Reprod.Home page
    A. R. Baerwald, G. P. Adams, and R. A. Pierson
    Characterization of Ovarian Follicular Wave Dynamics in Women
    Biol Reprod, September 1, 2003; 69(3): 1023 - 1031.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    Home page
    Hum ReprodHome page
    K.L.T. Schmidt, A.G. Byskov, A. Nyboe Andersen, J. Muller, and C. Yding Andersen
    Density and distribution of primordial follicles in single pieces of cortex from 21 patients and in individual pieces of cortex from three entire human ovaries
    Hum. Reprod., June 1, 2003; 18(6): 1158 - 1164.
    [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]


    This Article
    Right arrow Abstract Freely available
    Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
    Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
    Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
    Right arrow Citation Map
    Services
    Right arrow Email this article to a friend
    Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
    Right arrow Similar articles in PubMed
    Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
    Right arrow Download to citation manager
    Right arrow reprints & permissions
    Citing Articles
    Right arrow Citing Articles via HighWire
    Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
    Google Scholar
    Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
    Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.
    Right arrow Search for Related Content
    PubMed
    Right arrow PubMed Citation
    Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
    Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.
    Agricola
    Right arrow Articles by de Bruin, J.P.
    Right arrow Articles by te Velde, E.R.


    HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS