|
|
||||||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Gamete Biology; |
Departments of Physiology & Biophysics,3 Neurobiology & Developmental Sciences,4 Geriatrics5 and Immunology & Microbiology,6 and the Arkansas Cancer Research Center,7 University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, Arkansas 72205
CNRS UMR6061,8 Genetique et Developpement, Universite de Rennes 1, 35043 Rennes, France
ABSTRACT
In contrast to the well-defined role of Ca2+ signals during mitosis, the contribution of Ca2+ signaling to meiosis progression is controversial, despite several decades of investigating the role of Ca2+ and its effectors in vertebrate oocyte maturation. We have previously shown that during Xenopus oocyte maturation, Ca2+ signals are dispensable for entry into meiosis and for germinal vesicle breakdown. However, normal Ca2+ homeostasis is essential for completion of meiosis I and extrusion of the first polar body. In this study, we test the contribution of several downstream effectors in mediating the Ca2+ effects during oocyte maturation. We show that calmodulin and calcium-calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CAMK2) are not critical downstream Ca2+ effectors during meiotic maturation. In contrast, accumulation of Aurora kinase A (AURKA) protein is disrupted in cells deprived of Ca2+ signals. Since AURKA is required for bipolar spindle formation, failure to accumulate AURKA may contribute to the defective spindle phenotype following Ca2+ deprivation. These findings argue that Ca2+ homeostasis is important in establishing the oocyte's competence to undergo maturation in preparation for fertilization and embryonic development.
Aurora kinase A, calcium, gamete biology, meiosis, oocyte development
Intracellular Ca2+ signals are ubiquitous and regulate a plethora of cell physiological and developmental processes, including contraction, secretion, transcription, cell proliferation, and cell death. The ultimate cellular response to environmental and intrinsic cues integrates a multitude of signaling cascades. Therefore, cellular and developmental decisions are the outcome of often competing signaling processes that include significant crosstalk and feedback mechanisms, allowing tighter regulation of critical differentiation pathways. A fundamental developmental decision that initiates multicellular organism development is oocyte maturation. Oocyte maturation is a complex cellular differentiation that prepares the egg for fertilization and early embryonic development [1]. In vertebrates, oocyte maturation includes transition through meiosis and arrest at metaphase II until fertilization. This nuclear maturation is coupled to cytoplasmic maturation, including dramatic morphological and mechanistic alterations that are essential for the egg-to-embryo transition [1, 2]. As might be expected for such a complex cellular differentiation, several signaling cascades regulate oocyte maturation, culminating in the activation of maturation-promoting factor (MPF) [1, 3].
The role of Ca2+ signaling in regulating oocyte maturation has been of wide interest, given that Ca2+ signals have been convincingly shown to play a role in mitosis and during egg activation at fertilization. During mitosis, Ca2+ signals are involved in nuclear envelope breakdown [4], anaphase onset [5], and cell cleavage [6]. A variety of genetic and biochemical evidence supports a role for Ca2+ and its downstream effectors calmodulin and CAMK2 in mitosis and following fertilization [7–9]. In contrast, the role of Ca2+ signals during vertebrate oocyte meiosis remains contentious [10–12]. In Xenopus, early reports argued that a Ca2+ rise is sufficient to induce oocyte maturation [13–15], and injection of Ca2+ buffers block maturation [10, 14]. Whether Ca2+ signals are induced downstream of progesterone during Xenopus oocyte maturation is also controversial [16–20]. These conflicting reports argue that in Xenopus the relationship between Ca2+ and oocyte maturation is complex. Studies regarding the role of Ca2+ during mammalian oocyte maturation also produce conflicting results [11, 21].
We have previously shown that in Xenopus, cytoplasmic Ca2+ negatively regulates meiosis entry, yet it is required for the completion of meiosis I [22]. This dual role of Ca2+ signals during oocyte maturation partly explains the controversy surrounding this topic. The goal of this study was to better define the signaling cascade(s) downstream of Ca2+ involved in regulating oocyte maturation.
Gamete Preparation and Treatments
Xenopus oocytes were obtained as previously described in Machaca and Haun [23]. Frogs were purchased from Xenopus Express. Oocyte maturation was induced with 5 µg/ml progesterone. Germinal vesicle breakdown (GVBD) was detected visually by the appearance of a white spot at the animal pole of the cell and was confirmed by bisecting the cell into halves and detecting the nucleus after methanol fixation. The control L-15 solution contained 0.63 mM Ca2+. Ca2+ was buffered at 50 µmol/L in the low solution as calculated using the MaxChelator program (http://www.stanford.edu/
cpatton/maxc.html) by the addition of 0.58 mM EGTA. Maintenance and care for Xenopus frogs have been reviewed and approved by the UAMS Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC).
Lactacystin, MG-132, AIP, MLCK, MLCK control peptide, and calmidazolium were purchased from Calbiochem; thapsigargin was purchased from Molecular Probes; and fluphenazine dihydrochloride was purchased from Sigma. Messenger RNA for injection into oocytes was transcribed in vitro using the mMESSAGE mMACHINE T7 transcription kit (Ambion). The anti-Eg2 mAb was previously described [24].
Cells were fixed 3 h after GVBD in 100% methanol and stored at –20°C overnight. After rehydration in TBS/methanol (1:1) for 20 min, oocytes were washed twice with TBS for 15 min each and blocked for 3 h in TBS containing 2% BSA. Oocytes then were immunolabeled with an anti-
-tubulin monoclonal antibody (DM1A; Sigma) in TBS containing 2% BSA, followed by a Cy2-conjugated donkey anti-mouse secondary (Jackson) for 24 h each. The oocytes were washed five times in TBS for 24 h and stained with 1 µM Sytox Orange (Molecular Probes). After staining, cells were washed in TBS for 1 h, dehydrated in 100% methanol for 30 min, and cleared in benzyl alcohol-benzyl benzoate (1:2). Spindle structure images were collected on a Zeiss LSM510 confocal or on an Olympus Fluoview confocal. In some experiments, chromosome structure and polar body emission were visualized using Sytox Orange labeling without staining the spindle.
Polyadenylation of endogenous mRNA species was assessed by RNA ligation-coupled RT-PCR, modified slightly from a previously described technique [25]. Total oocyte RNA (4 µg) from pools of five or six oocytes was ligated to 0.4 µg P1 anchor primer [25] in a 10-µl reaction using T4 RNA ligase (New England Biolabs) according to manufacturer's directions. The whole 10-µl RNA ligation reaction was used in a 50-µl reverse transcription reaction using Superscript III (Invitrogen), according to manufacturer's directions using 0.4 µg P1' as the reverse primer [25]. A total of 1 µl of this cDNA preparation was used in each 50-µl PCR reaction using Platinum Taq (Invitrogen), according to manufacturer's directions. Polymerase chain reaction was performed for 40 cycles using a 56°C annealing temperature and 1.5 mM final concentration of Mg2+. For optimal resolution, specific primers used were designed to be 70–90 nucleotides from the poly(A) addition site [26] according to sequence in GenBank: the accession numbers are Z17206 (Eg2, AURKA), X13311 (MOS), and J03166 (cyclin B1). The primers used were Cyclin B1: GTG GCA TTC CAA TTG TGT ATT GTT; AURKA: GTT TCA ATC TTG TAT GTC CTT TTA; and MOS: GTT GCA TTG CTG TTT AAG TGG TAA.
Wild-type (wt) and mutant CAMK2A clones were obtained from H. Schulman [27]. They were subcloned into pSGEM vector by cutting with PstI and HindIII. pSGEM-CAMK2A (wt), CAMK2A dominant-negative (dn, K42M), and CAMK2A constitutively active (ca, T286D) were linearized with NheI and transcribed with T7 polymerase. Rat calmodulin clones were provided by the Adelman Lab. Both wt and mutant calmodulin (with a D-to-A mutation in all four EF hand motifs) were cloned into pBF, as previously described [28]. RNA from calmodulin (CALM) clones was generated by linearizing them with MluI and transcribing with SP6 polymerase.
Proteasome-specific activity was evaluated in oocyte lysates employing a biotinylated proteasome activity profiling probe, Ada-Lys (biotinyl)-(Ahx) 3-(Leu) 3-vinyl sulphone (BIOMOL). This probe specifically targets the active catalytic sites of the proteasome [29]. Oocytes were lysed in buffer containing 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4), 5 mM MgCl2, 250 mM sucrose, and 2 mM ATP. Lysates equalized for protein (30 µg) were labeled with 5 µM biotinylated probe in a reaction buffer containing 50 mM Tris-HCl (pH 7.4), 5 mM MgCl2, 2 mM ATP, and 2 mM dithiothreitol for 2 h at 37°C. Labeling reactions were quenched by the addition of SDS sample buffer and boiling for 5 min. Samples were resolved by 12% SDS-PAGE, transferred to nitrocellulose membranes, immunoblotted with streptavidin conjugated to horseradish peroxidase and detected using Enhanced Chemiluminescence (Amersham Biosciences). For the studies using proteasomal inhibitors, the inhibitors were present only during the maturation phase of the oocytes and were not added to the proteasome activity assay after oocyte lysis.
As we have previously shown, maturing oocytes in low extracellular Ca2+ (L-Ca; Ca2+ buffered at 50 µmol/L) enhances the rate of entry into meiosis as marked by GVBD (Fig. 1A) [22]. This enhancement is significantly more pronounced when intracellular Ca2+ stores are depleted with thapsigargin (Thaps) in L-Ca medium, thus depriving oocytes of both intracellular and extracellular Ca2+ signals (Fig. 1A). This faster maturation rate is associated, as would be expected, with premature activation of the MAPK-MPF signaling cascade [22], which regulates progression through oocyte maturation.
|
Progesterone-dependent Xenopus oocyte maturation is believed to be initiated by a cell surface G protein-coupled receptor [30, 31], rapidly (5–10 min) leading to inhibition of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PKA) [32]. After a significant time delay (>1–2 h) and through largely unknown steps, mRNA translation of MOS and other regulators is induced through polyadenylation [33, 34], ultimately leading to the activation of MPF [3]. Maturation-promoting factor is the primary activity that regulates G2/M transition in both mitosis and meiosis, and it consists of a catalytic p34cdc2 Ser/Thr kinase subunit (CDK1) and a regulatory cyclin B subunit [35].
One of the earliest known molecular events downstream of PKA inhibition is translational regulation of maternal mRNAs through polyadenylation. Maternal mRNA polyadenylation is regulated in a temporal fashion through distinct 3' UTR regulatory elements [26, 36]. Some early-class mRNAs, such as MOS, are polyadenylated and translated prior to GVBD under the control of musashi 3' UTR regulator elements, whereas late-class mRNAs, such as cyclin B1, are polyadenylated and translated after GVBD under the control of late-acting cytoplasmic polyadenylation elements [26, 37]. We were interested in testing the effect of Ca2+ deprivation on the timing of polyadenylation of early- and late-class mRNAs. As shown in Figure 1B, in Ca2+-deprived oocytes, polyadenylation of MOS mRNA occurs as early as 2–3 h after progesterone addition (observed as an increase in PCR product size), compared with 4–5 h for control oocytes matured in normal Ca2+ medium. In contrast, the pattern of the late cyclin B1 mRNA polyadenylation occurs coincidently with GVBD in control and Ca2+-deprived oocytes. In Figure 1B, G0 refers to the time point at which the first cells in the population undergo GVBD, and G50 refers to when 50% of the cells in the population reach GVBD. These data show that the premature activation of the MOS-MAPK signaling cascade in Ca2+-deprived cells is likely due to a more rapid activation of the polyadenylation machinery regulating early-class maternal mRNA translational activation.
The experiments in Figure 1, A and B, were performed on oocyte populations from different donor females. There typically are significant variations in the rate of oocyte maturation in the population between different females, as illustrated in Figure 1, A and B. Oocytes in Figure 1A matured at a faster rate than those from the female in Figure 1B. Nonetheless, despite these differences in the rate of maturation, qualitatively the differences described in this manuscript in terms of Ca2+ deprivation and polyadenylation are consistently observed.
Another interesting phenotype of Ca2+-deprived oocytes is their inability to complete meiosis I and extrude the first polar body (Fig. 1C) [22]. Analyzing polar body emission over time reveals that the majority of oocytes matured in control medium complete meiosis I and extrude a polar body 2 h after GVBD. In contrast, oocytes matured in L-Ca medium, treated with thapsigargin, or injected with BATPA (not shown) fail to extrude a polar body up to 4 h after GVBD.
Careful analyses of spindle structure in Ca2+-deprived cells reveal that the primary defect is the inability of the first meiotic spindle to elongate in the absence of Ca2+ signals (Fig. 1D). Simply maturing oocyte in L-Ca medium (Fig. 1D) or blocking Ca2+ signals by BAPTA injection or thapsigargin treatment (not shown) inhibits spindle elongation. Ca2+-deprived cells assemble a compact spindle around the chromosomes but never progress to the elongated bipolar spindle observed in control cells (Fig. 1D). The inability of the spindle to elongate explains the defect in polar body emission observed in meiosis I.
Role of Ca2+-Calmodulin-Dependent Protein Kinase 2 (CAMK2)
We then tested the involvement of Ca2+-calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II (CAMK2) in the defects observed in Ca2+-deprived oocytes during maturation. This is because CAMK2 is a prominent downstream effector of Ca2+ signals and because it has been functionally implicated in meiosis. For example, CAMK2 has been shown to physically associate with the meiotic spindle in mouse eggs and to be important for the transition into anaphase during meiosis II [38, 39]. Furthermore, inhibition of CAMK2 activity in mouse oocytes blocks polar body emission [40], arguing that CAMK2 inhibition may be responsible for the defects observed following Ca2+ deprivation during Xenopus oocyte maturation. To test whether this is the case, we modulated CAMK2 activity by injecting oocytes with AIP, a potent and specific CAMK2 inhibitory peptide [41]. AIP injection (10 µM) did not affect the extent of GVBD in the population, but did significantly (P = 0.004) enhance the rate at which cells reach GVBD (Fig. 2A). Although this enhancement is consistent with a potential role for CAMK2 in effecting Ca2+ signals during oocyte maturation, it did not reach the levels of enhancement achieved by maturing oocytes in L-Ca medium or following Thaps treatment (Fig. 2A). Furthermore, AIP injection had no effect on the rate of GVBD when cells were pretreated with Thaps (Fig. 2A, T-AIP).
|
We wanted to confirm the AIP result by expressing wt, dominant-negative (CAMK2dn), and constitutively active (CAMK2ca) CAMK2A mutants (Fig. 2B) [42]. Wild-type CAMK2A injection did not significantly (P = 0.083) affect the rate of maturation compared with the control (Fig. 2B). Injection of CAMK2dn tended to slow down the rate of maturation; however, the time to G50 did not reach statistical significance compared with wt CAMK2A injections (P = 0.064; Fig. 2B). CAMK2ca enhanced the rate of maturation (P = 0.034) compared with wt CAMK2A injection (Fig. 2B). None of the CAMK2A injections significantly affected the extent of maturation (Fig. 2B). These results argue that CAMK2 is not a downstream effector of Ca2+ signals in terms of setting the rate of maturation because, in contrast to Ca2+ deprivation, CAMK2dn slowed down the rate of maturation, and CAMK2ca enhanced it (Fig. 2B). If CAMK2 was indeed a downstream Ca2+ effector, one expects that CAMK2dn should enhance the rate of maturation in a fashion similar to Ca2+ deprivation. Given the fact that CAMK2 could impact a multitude of signaling cascades, the observed effects of overexpression of either the constitutively active or dn mutants of CAMK2 could be indirect. This is plausible, since AIP produces an opposite effect of CAMK2dn on the rate of maturation (Fig. 2B). Therefore, together these results argue that CAMK2 is not a major player in modulating the rate of oocyte maturation.
We then tested the role of CAMK2 in completion of meiosis I and first polar body emission. Maturing oocytes in L-Ca medium inhibit polar body emission (Fig. 2C). In contrast, AIP injection or injection of wt or dn CAMK2A did not inhibit the ability of oocytes to extrude a polar body (Fig. 2C). It was not possible to test the effect of the constitutively active CAMK2A mutant in these experiments, because cells expressing CAMK2ca did not survive long enough after GVBD to allow for first polar body extrusion. These results indicate that CAMK2 is not important for spindle formation in Xenopus oocytes.
Calmodulin (CALM) is an excellent candidate for transmitting Ca2+ signals to downstream effectors during oocyte maturation, especially in the context of the spindle elongation defect. CALM contains four Ca2+-binding EF hands and acts as the Ca2+ sensor for many cellular functions [43]. CALM localizes to the spindle poles [44]. Furthermore, CALM confers Ca2+ sensitivity to dynein, where Ca2+-CALM binds to dynein and enhances its motor activity [45, 46]. This is relevant, since dynein localizes to the spindle [47, 48], regulates microtubule dynamics [49], and is critical for the formation of a normal spindle in Xenopus [49, 50]. In addition to its interactions with dynein, CALM interacts with other components at the spindle pole, primarily the 110-kDa spindle pole component, and this interaction is essential for normal spindle formation [51–53]. It is therefore possible that the spindle defect observed in meiosis I of Ca2+-deprived cells is due to disruption of CALM function/localization. In addition, CALM has been postulated to play a role in the progression of oocyte maturation in Xenopus, since CALM levels increase during maturation [54], and CALM injection has been reported to induce low levels of maturation, although this result was not reproducible [18, 55–57].
To test the role of CALM in oocyte maturation and meiosis I spindle formation, we inhibited CALM function with calmidazolium (CDZ) or fluphenazine (FLZ). Calmidazolium is an imidazole compound that acts as a specific CALM antagonist by strongly binding to the hydrophobic surface of CALM, preventing the binding of Ca2+ and, thus, the correct folding of active CALM [58]. Fluphenazine is an antipsychotic drug that blocks CALM interaction with a variety of downstream effectors [59]. Calmidazolium did not affect the rate or extent of entry into meiosis, nor did it significantly alter spindle structure (Fig. 3A). It did, however, have a significant effect on the ability of the oocyte to extrude a polar body (Fig. 3A), although these effects were not nearly as dramatic as maturing oocytes in the absence of extracellular Ca2+. In contrast, as previously reported for FLZ [60] and other CALM antagonists [61, 62], FLZ enhances the rate of oocyte maturation in a manner consistent with Ca2+ deprivation without affecting maximal GVBD (Fig. 3B). Furthermore, FLZ was more likely to lead to spindle defects, although the effects were quite variable (Fig. 3B) yet, surprisingly, this did not affect the ability of the oocytes to extrude a polar body.
|
The differential effect of FLZ and CDZ on the rate of maturation is not surprising, since CDZ has been previously reported not to effectively inhibit certain CALM-dependent processes where CALM is tightly associated with its downstream effector, as for L-type Ca2+ channels [63] and small-conductance Ca2+-activated K channels [64]. Therefore, the FLZ data argue that CALM is involved in regulating the rate of oocyte maturation. However, attempts to confirm the effects of a pharmacological block of CALM on the rate of maturation using either injection of a CALM inhibitory peptide (MLCK peptide) or a CALM mutant with all four EF hands mutated (CALMs 1, 2, 3, 4) and thus unable to bind Ca2+ were unsuccessful (Table 1). In either case, these treatments were ineffective at enhancing the rate of maturation, bringing into question the importance of CALM in regulating the rate of maturation. Therefore, as is the case with CAMK2, the fact that different approaches to interfere with CALM function produce disparate results in terms of controlling the rate of oocyte maturation argues that CALM is not a critical determinant of the processes by which Ca2+ regulates progression through maturation.
|
In contrast to the effects of CALM inhibition on the rate of maturation, consistent results were obtained on polar body emission. None of the experimental manipulations of CALM inhibited polar body emission to levels similar to Ca2+ deprivation (Fig. 3 and Table 1). This argues that the Ca2+ effects on spindle formation and polar body emission are not mediated through CALM.
The inability of Ca2+-deprived oocytes to complete meiosis normally and extrude a polar body is interesting because this nuclear defect occurs while the kinetics of the MAPK-MPF cascade proceed normally [22]. These observations suggest that Ca2+ deprivation uncouples the kinase signaling cascade regulating oocyte maturation from the nuclear meiotic events. Several other experimental manipulations, such as inhibition of the MAPK cascade [65], downregulation of MPF [66], and inhibition of protein synthesis [67], lead to a meiosis I arrest that is coupled to an interphaselike state. In contrast, Ca2+ deprivation does not affect the MAPK-MPF kinase signaling cascade, yet it disrupts spindle elongation in meiosis I and prevents polar body emission. Interestingly, manipulation of the Aurora kinases produces a similar phenotype. Downregulation of Aurora B in Caenorhabditis elegans inhibits polar body extrusion in meiosis I [68]. In Xenopus oocytes, injection of anti-AURKA antibodies inhibits polar body extrusion without affecting chromosome condensation or MPF activity [69]. In addition, expression of a constitutively active AURKA in Xenopus oocytes leads to a meiosis I arrest, with high MPF activity and condensed chromosomes but defective spindles [70]. Therefore, manipulating AURKA activity in Xenopus oocytes phenocopies Ca2+ deprivation, arguing that AURKA regulation may have a Ca2+-dependent component. To test this possibility, we measured the levels of AURKA in control and Ca2+-deprived oocytes throughout the maturation process (Fig. 4A). As previously shown [71], AURKA gradually accumulates during maturation, especially after GVBD (Fig. 4A). In contrast, AURKA accumulation is significantly attenuated during maturation of Ca2+-deprived, Thaps-treated oocytes (Fig. 4A). Although the tubulin loading control shows more protein loading toward the later time points in both the low Ca2+ and Thaps treatments (Fig. 4A), this still correlates with lower accumulated levels of AURKA protein, showing that the ability of cells deprived of Ca2+ signals to accumulate AURKA is compromised.
|
Supporting the time course data, when lysates are prepared at different time points during maturation, the inhibition of AURKA accumulation in Ca2+-deprived cells is apparent (Fig. 4B). For this experiment, we isolated lysates from: (1) oocytes (oocytes); (2) eggs, which have undergone GVBD >3 h earlier; (3) when cells in the population first reach GVBD (G0); (4) when 50% of the cells in the population reach GVBD (G50)—in this case, lysates from both cells with a white spot (w) and those without (nw) were collected—and (5) when 100% of the cells in the population reach GVBD (G100). Similar to the time course data (Fig. 4A), Ca2+-deprived cells are less efficient at accumulating AURKA compared with controls (Fig. 4B).
One possibility that we considered to explain the lack of AURKA accumulation in Ca2+-deprived cells was the failure to polyadenylate the early class AURKA mRNA [26, 72]. However, similar to the MOS mRNA (Fig. 1B), Thaps treatment led to an accelerated initiation of endogenous AURKA mRNA polyadenylation (Fig. 4C). This argues that the lack of AURKA accumulation following disruption of Ca2+ homeostasis is not due to differential polyadenylation, but rather either reflects a specific defect in AURKA mRNA translation or posttranslational stabilization of AURKA protein.
One possibility to explain the AURKA results is modulation of proteasome activity following Ca2+ deprivation. The 26S proteasome regulates protein degradation following polyubiquitination and has been implicated in oocyte meiosis in several species. Proteasome activity increases in a Ca2+-dependent fashion during ascidian and Xenopus egg activation [73, 74]; the proteasome associates with the spindle during rat oocyte meiosis; and proteasome inhibitors block polar body extrusion [75]. Furthermore, the levels of certain critical regulators of Xenopus oocyte maturation, such as CPEB and MOS, are dependent on the proteasome [76, 77]. Based on these findings, we were interested in testing the role of the proteasome in regulating oocyte maturation following Ca2+ deprivation. Proteasome activity was not affected when cells were matured in L-Ca medium or when they were treated with thapsigargin (Fig. 5A). Proteasome activity is reflected in band intensity of the different proteasomal subunits, given the specific labeling using a biotinylated proteasome activity profiling probe, as explained in Materials and Methods (Fig. 5A). We further tested the ability of two proteasome inhibitors, lactacystin and MG132, to block Xenopus oocyte proteasome activity. Lactacystin (at the doses employed) was ineffective at blocking the proteasome, whereas MG132 inhibited proteasome activity in a dose-dependent fashion (Fig. 5A). Nevertheless, oocytes treated with either inhibitor matured with kinetics similar to those in control cells (Fig. 5B), showing that proteasome inhibition is not sufficient to enhance the rate of oocyte maturation. These data argue that modulation of proteasome function is not responsible for the defective AURKA accumulation, since proteasome activity is not altered following Ca2+ deprivation. Furthermore, the activation of the MAPK cascade, which depends on MOS accumulation, occurs earlier in Ca2+-deprived cells [22], consistent with a lack of effect of Ca2+ deprivation on proteasome activity.
|
Depriving Xenopus oocytes of Ca2+ signals does not affect their ability to enter meiosis or undergo GVBD, but it results in a dramatically disrupted spindle structure and a lack of polar body emission [22]. In Ca2+-deprived oocytes, the meiosis I spindle does not elongate into a bipolar spindle (Fig. 1D), which could form the basis for the lack of polar body emission. It is unclear why disrupting Ca2+ homeostasis leads to defective spindles. One possibility is that Ca2+ chelation directly affects microtubule assembly, as previously described [78, 79]. Another explanation for the Ca2+-dependent meiosis I defect would be faulty signaling directly downstream of Ca2+. This was the incentive for us to test two ubiquitous Ca2+-dependent downstream effectors, calmodulin and CAMK2. However, our results argue that neither of these effectors is involved in the defects observed following Ca2+ deprivation during oocyte maturation. Interfering with CALM or CAMK2 function using various approaches produces disparate effects that are inconsistent with the effect of Ca2+ deprivation on the rate of progression of oocyte maturation (Figs. 2 and 3). This argues that CALM-CAMK2 is not a critical effector of Ca2+ signals during oocyte maturation in terms of setting the rate of maturation. In a similar fashion, disruption of either CALM or CAMK2 function did not significantly and consistently affect the ability of maturing oocytes to extrude a polar body. We conclude from these results that the phenotypes observed following Ca2+ deprivation (i.e., faster maturation and lack of polar body emission) are not due to disruption of the CALM-CAMK2 signaling axis.
Ca2+ deprivation results in a faster maturation rate, raising the possibility that this could underlie the meiosis I defect. In that context, tight coordination of different signaling cascades is essential for timely progression through oocyte maturation [3]. We were therefore interested in testing whether depriving oocytes of Ca2+ signals somehow disrupts this tight coordination. AURKA was an obvious target to test, because altering AURKA activity phenocopies the Ca2+ deprivation-dependent spindle defect [69, 70]. Furthermore, the Aurora family encodes Ser/Thr kinases that localize to the spindle poles and are crucial for spindle assembly during both meiosis and mitosis [80–82].
AURKA protein gradually accumulates during oocyte maturation (Fig. 4A), and this increase is important for AURKA function during meiosis [71]. Although the ability of AURKA to accumulate in Ca2+-deprived oocytes is compromised (Fig. 4, A and B), this defect is not correlated with a failure to polyadenylate AURKA mRNA prior to GVBD (Fig. 4C). These findings indicate that unlike the translation of MOS and activation of MAP kinase signaling, AURKA mRNA translation is specifically attenuated, or the newly synthesized AURKA protein is destabilized. The failure to accumulate AURKA protein could contribute to the spindle elongation defect and the inability of Ca2+-deprived oocytes to extrude a polar body, because the levels of AURKA are critical for normal progression through meiosis [69, 70]. However, it is not clear at this point whether there exists a cause-effect relationship between the lack of AURKA accumulation and the defective spindle phenotype observed in Ca2+-deprived cells. Unfortunately, directly testing this relationship is technically difficult because the levels of AURKA have to be tightly controlled. Either interfering with AURKA function or increasing it leads to defective spindles and disrupts meiosis I completion [69, 70].
It remains unclear why AURKA accumulation is disrupted following Ca2+ deprivation, although we can rule out direct effects on the proteasome (Fig. 5). Interfering with Ca2+ signaling enhances the rate at which oocytes mature by activating the MAPK-MPF cascade earlier [22]. This is due to a more rapid polyadenylation of early-class mRNAs, such as MOS (Fig. 1B). AURKA mRNA is also polyadenylated earlier in Ca2+-deprived cells, but this is associated with defective accumulation of AURKA. The fact that AURKA accumulation is not necessarily dependent on polyadenylation [71] may partially explain the differential effect of Ca2+ deprivation on the MOS-MAPK cascade versus AURKA. Accumulation of AURKA is a balance between both mRNA translation and AURKA protein degradation rates. Since proteasome activity is not directly affected in Ca2+-deprived oocytes, Ca2+ deprivation could be inhibiting AURKA accumulation by affecting AURKA mRNA de-repression independently of polyadenylation and/or AURKA protein stability.
Together, our data argue that the effects of Ca2+ deprivation on oocyte maturation are mediated through Ca2+-dependent regulation of mRNA translation. CPEB is a central player in regulating translation during oocyte maturation, and recent evidence argues that CPEB phosphorylation is regulated by the Xenopus Rho-family guanine nucleotide exchange factor [83, 84], raising the possibility that some of the Ca2+-dependent effects on mRNA translation could be mediated through this pathway.
Taken together, our data argue that when Ca2+ homeostasis is disrupted, this breaks down the coordination between the MAPK-MPF signaling cascade and AURKA accumulation, potentially contributing to the spindle formation defects. Ca2+ appears to mediate these effects through regulation of maternal mRNA translation, which is crucial for oocyte maturation. Therefore, Ca2+ homeostasis is a critical determinant of the oocyte's competence to undergo maturation in preparation for fertilization. If Ca2+ homeostasis is disrupted, this signals a compromised oocyte that is unlikely to achieve normal developmental competence. Therefore, normal Ca2+ homeostasis is an important factor in coordinating biochemical and nuclear meiotic events during oocyte maturation.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
We are grateful to Howard Schulman for providing the wild-type, dominant-negative, and constitutively active CAMK2A clones, and to Kevin Foskett and John Adelman for the wild-type and mutant CALM clones.
FOOTNOTES
1Supported by National Institutes of Health grants GM-61829 (K.M.), HD35688 (A.M.M.), AG13081 (U.P.), and RR20146 (A.C.). C.P. is funded by grants from the CNRS and LNCC (équipe labellisée). ![]()
Correspondence: 2Khaled Machaca, Department of Physiology & Biophysics, 4301 West Markham St., Slot 505, University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences (UAMS), Little Rock, AR 72205. FAX: 501 686 8167; e-mail: kamachaca{at}uams.edu.
Received: 26 June 2007.
First decision: 7 August 2007.
Accepted: 30 November 2007.
REFERENCES
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |